CarJinga

Used Cars for Sale Near Me in Bay Shore, NY

68 vehicles available from local dealers, rated against the local market.

Jeep Compass

2017 Jeep Compass

8.3/10Great Deal

Sport 4x4 *Ltd Avail*

$10,990$2,158 below market

Est. $205/mo

85,394 miBay Shore, NYDrive Auto Sales
Toyota Tacoma

2016 Toyota Tacoma

10.0/10Great Deal

4WD Access Cab I4 AT SR5 (Natl)

$19,990$6,674 below market

Est. $373/mo

75,701 miBay Shore, NYDrive Auto Sales
Honda Civic

2014 Honda Civic

10.0/10Great Deal

4dr CVT LX

$8,880$5,793 below market

Est. $166/mo

63,512 miBay Shore, NYDrive Auto Sales
Chevrolet Silverado

2019 Chevrolet Silverado

7.3/10Great Deal

Double Cab LT

$24,990$3,271 below market

Est. $467/mo

52,943 miBay Shore, NYDrive Auto Sales
Honda Fit

2007 Honda Fit

10.0/10Great Deal

5dr HB AT Sport

$5,550$2,202 below market

Est. $103/mo

125,132 miBay Shore, NYDrive Auto Sales
Kia Forte

2017 Kia Forte

7.8/10Great Deal

LX Auto

$9,990$1,616 below market

Est. $187/mo

46,917 miBay Shore, NYDrive Auto Sales
Chevrolet Cruze

2014 Chevrolet Cruze

8.0/10Great Deal

4dr Sdn Auto 1LT

$7,550$1,324 below market

Est. $140/mo

85,710 miBay Shore, NYDrive Auto Sales
Volkswagen Jetta

2016 Volkswagen Jetta

10.0/10Great Deal

4dr Man 1.4T S

$8,995$3,248 below market

Est. $168/mo

57,020 miBay Shore, NYDrive Auto Sales
Hyundai Accent

2014 Hyundai Accent

6.8/10Good Deal

4dr Sdn Auto GLS

$8,990$866 below market

Est. $168/mo

58,780 miBay Shore, NYDrive Auto Sales
Toyota Sequoia

2006 Toyota Sequoia

6.0/10Good Deal

4dr SR5 4WD (SE)

$6,990$369 below market

Est. $131/mo

223,914 miBay Shore, NYDrive Auto Sales
BMW M4

2015 BMW M4

6.9/10Good Deal

2dr Cpe

$36,990$3,942 below market

Est. $691/mo

26,664 miBay Shore, NYDrive Auto Sales
Honda Civic

2013 Honda Civic

6.2/10Good Deal

4dr Auto EX

$12,990$813 below market

Est. $243/mo

67,221 miBay Shore, NYDrive Auto Sales
Honda Accord

2016 Honda Accord

6.3/10Good Deal

4dr I4 CVT Sport w/Honda Sensing

$17,499$1,250 below market

Est. $328/mo

36,853 miBay Shore, NYDrive Auto Sales
Subaru Forester

2016 Subaru Forester

5.4/10Fair Price

4dr CVT 2.5i Premium PZEV

$13,990$286 below market

Est. $261/mo

74,185 miBay Shore, NYDrive Auto Sales
Ford Mustang

2011 Ford Mustang

4.1/10Fair Price

2dr Cpe GT Premium

$19,990

Est. $373/mo

63,318 miBay Shore, NYDrive Auto Sales
Mitsubishi Outlander Sport

2014 Mitsubishi Outlander Sport

4.6/10Fair Price

AWD 4dr CVT ES

$11,495

Est. $216/mo

58,653 miBay Shore, NYDrive Auto Sales
Hyundai Kona

2019 Hyundai Kona

5.2/10Fair Price

SE Auto AWD

$16,990$215 below market

Est. $317/mo

15,235 miBay Shore, NYDrive Auto Sales
Toyota RAV4

2021 Toyota RAV4

4.5/10Fair Price

Hybrid LE AWD (Natl)

$25,575

Est. $477/mo

72,679 miBay Shore, NYDrive Auto Sales
Nissan NV200

2015 Nissan NV200

4.5/10Fair Price

I4 SV

$12,990

Est. $243/mo

99,862 miBay Shore, NYDrive Auto Sales
Toyota Corolla

2020 Toyota Corolla

5.1/10Fair Price

XSE CVT (Natl)

$19,990$80 below market

Est. $373/mo

9,478 miBay Shore, NYDrive Auto Sales
Mercedes-Benz C-Class

2014 Mercedes-Benz C-Class

0.0/10High Price

4dr Sdn C 300 Sport 4MATIC

$19,880

Est. $371/mo

41,412 miBay Shore, NYDrive Auto Sales
Nissan Maxima

2019 Nissan Maxima

0.5/10High Price

S 3.5L

$21,990

Est. $411/mo

24,052 miBay Shore, NYDrive Auto Sales
Honda Odyssey

2017 Honda Odyssey

0.4/10High Price

EX-L w/Navi Auto

$23,990

Est. $448/mo

38,373 miBay Shore, NYDrive Auto Sales
Mercedes-Benz C-Class

2018 Mercedes-Benz C-Class

0.0/10High Price

C 300 4MATIC Sedan

$28,990

Est. $542/mo

22,713 miBay Shore, NYDrive Auto Sales

Used car market in Bay Shore, NY

CarJinga has 68 used cars for sale in Bay Shore, listed by 1 dealer. The typical asking price is about $25,600, and most cars here are priced between $10,000 and $47,000. The average car listed has around 49,000 miles and is a 2016 model year.

Mercedes-Benz, Honda and Chevrolet are the best-stocked brands in Bay Shore right now.

Shopping to a budget? 7 cars are listed at $10,000 or less, and 23 are listed at $20,000 or less.

Every listing is compared with similar cars for sale and rated Great, Good, Fair or High, so you can see how a price stacks up before you visit. Dealer inventory is refreshed daily. You can also look at all used cars for sale in New York.

Used Cars by Brand in Bay Shore, NY

Shop Used Cars by Price in Bay Shore, NY

Popular Models in Bay Shore, NY

Used Car Dealers in Bay Shore, NY

Frequently Asked Questions

How many used cars are for sale in Bay Shore, NY?

68 used cars are listed for sale in Bay Shore, NY on CarJinga right now, from 1 local dealer.

What's the cheapest used car for sale in Bay Shore, NY?

There is 1 used car for sale in Bay Shore, NY under $6,000 right now.

What are the most popular used cars for sale in Bay Shore, NY?

The most-listed used cars for sale in Bay Shore, NY right now are the Honda Civic, Mercedes-Benz C-Class, Mercedes-Benz S-Class.

Where can I find cars for sale near me in Bay Shore, NY?

Local dealers with used cars for sale in Bay Shore, NY include Drive Auto Sales. Every listing on CarJinga is rated against the local market so you can see whether it's a fair price before you go.

Used Cars Near Bay Shore, NY